New: Unvault featured on Bloomberg  

Home
›
›
Sell Tiffany Jewelry Online
Sell your TIFFANY JEWELRY

Sell your Tiffany jewelry online with certainty

See what your Tiffany jewelry is really worth before you commit. Start with clear photos, review your itemized estimate, then ship only if the offer feels right. We buy your piece outright at the best price and pay you instantly - no consignment, no waiting.

★★★★★
4.9 · See Trustpilot reviews · “Excellent”
Insured shipping
Authenticated on camera
4.9 ★ Trustpilot rating
No-obligation to sell

Free insured FedEx label · nothing owed if you decline · shipped back free · payment sent 1 business day after acceptance

Prices update daily - your offer holds for 30 days.

Jewelry photograph
SELLERS TRUST UNVAULT

Transparent valuation. Sold only if you choose.

200,000+
Valuations completed
$140M+
Jewelry tracked
BBB Accredited
Guaranteed transparency accross valuations
ONLINE TIFFANY JEWELRY VALUATION

Your Tiffany jewelry valuation in 3 simple steps

See what your Tiffany jewelry could sell for before you decide what to do next. Start with a few photos, review your itemized estimate, then ship only if the offer feels right.

01

Upload photos

Step illustration
02

Receive your estimate

Step illustration
03

Sell when ready

Step illustration

In less than a minute, you’ll receive a detailed valuation.

Get Instant Valuation
Why Unvault

The best place to sell your Tiffany jewelry online

Traditional buyers make you ship first and hand you one opaque number. Unvault flips it: value first, full breakdown, sell only if you choose.

The old way
Pawn / mail-in
  • A fast offer with little explanation
  • Tiffany sterling treated like ordinary silver scrap
  • Unclear authentication standards
  • Consignment fees and waiting periods
  • Pressure to hand over the piece before you understand the value
The Unvault way
Value first
  • An itemized estimate before you ship
  • Brand, collection, and design considered alongside materials
  • Signatures, hallmarks, and construction reviewed
  • A direct best price offer, paid instantly, with no consignment wait
  • You decide whether to continue after reviewing the estimate
The value breakdown

What determines your Tiffany jewelry's resale value

Three things can decide what a Tiffany piece is worth on resale: whether it can be confirmed as Tiffany, what it is made of and how recognizable the design is, and the condition it is in today.

Section illustration

Authenticity starts with the details

There’s not one single detail that can confirm a Tiffany piece. In this case a specialist reads all of it together:

  • The Tiffany & Co. signature
  • Metal hallmarks such as 925, 750, 585 or PT950
  • The workmanship as well as how clasps and links are built
  • The model or serial markings

Then they check that it all agrees and matches how that piece was actually made.

Photograph these close and in focus: the engraving, every hallmark, the clasp inside and out, the backs of settings and charms, and the full piece.

A serial number does not prove authenticity on its own. Neither does a receipt. Both can be copied, and both can belong to a different piece.

Section illustration

Material and design shape the buyer pool

Materials set a floor. The design decides how far above it you go.

Sterling silver, 18k and 14k gold, platinum, diamonds and colored gemstones are all valued differently.

If a piece can be identified as part of a known family such as Return to Tiffany, Tiffany T, HardWear, Elsa Peretti or Jean Schlumberger, that widens the pool of buyers looking for it specifically. If it cannot be identified, it is valued on the metal, stones and workmanship alone. Signed pieces from other houses are covered on the designer jewelry page.

Signed Tiffany silver should not automatically be priced as scrap. If a buyer quotes you a silver weight and nothing else, they have not valued the piece. They have weighed it.

Section illustration

Condition and completeness affect the offer

Condition is judged as the piece stands today. This is what matters:

  • Wear and tear to edges, links and engraving
  • Any personal engraving added later
  • Resizing work and past repairs
  • Any missing components, such as a charm, a clasp, or one earring of a pair
  • Size of the piece
  • Current demand for that design

Box, pouch, receipt and service records help. They widen the buyer pool and speed up verification. They are not required.

WHAT SELLERS SAY ABOUT UNVAULT

Read what people say about selling with Unvault

4.9
★★★★★
Trustpilot rating · rated “Excellent”
BBB · A+ Accredited
Jewelers Board of Trade
★★★★★

I recently sold some jewelry to Unvault and was pleasantly surprised by how smooth and simple the process was. The entire transaction only took a few days and the payment was more than I expected. I also received great customer service. I will definitely work with them again.

✓ Verified sale
Irene
United States
Read on Trustpilot
★★★★★

Start to finish, what an awesome process- First, my jewelry was appraised as a digital estimate, then followed up with an email. A free packing label was sent; I dropped it off at my local Fedex store - received another email from Unvault that my box was received. Next step was receiving an email with offer, alongside a video appraisal showing every step of the unboxing. Once I agreed to offer, received email that check would arrive within 7-10 business days.Very pleased!

✓ Verified sale
Jorene Gmail
United States
Read on Trustpilot
★★★★★

I couldn't be happier with this experience. The submission process was super easy and painless, and the amount I got was surprisingly large (even larger than their initial estimate). Would give this service 10 stars if I could.

✓ Verified sale
Phyllis
United States
Read on Trustpilot

Recent Valuations

Sold
Sold jewelry item
$6,016
Ashlyn’s diamond ring
Sold
Sold jewelry item
$8,450
Alice’s oval halo ring
Sold
Sold jewelry item
$9,299
Steven’s diamond earrings
Sold
Sold jewelry item
$14,200
Priya’s diamond earrings
Sold
Sold jewelry item
$21,000
Jacquelyn’s eternity band
Sold
Sold jewelry item
$21,000
Jacquelyn’s eternity band
Questions, answered

Selling your Tiffany jewelry online - FAQs

Can I sell Tiffany jewelry without the original receipt, box, or pouch?

Yes. The piece itself carries its own evidence: the Tiffany & Co. signature, the hallmarks, the construction, and any model or serial markings. This is what a specialist would work from.

Accessories will help. A blue box, pouch, receipt or service record widens the buyer pool and speeds up verification. Missing them does not erase resale value.

Send the piece as it is, and photograph any partial documentation you have. Without accessories, more weight falls on the physical evidence, so photo quality matters more.

How can I tell whether my Tiffany jewelry is authentic?

You will want to read several things together, never one on its own:

  • The signature, and how it is engraved
  • Any hallmarks such as 925, 750, 585 or PT950
  • The weight along with the construction
  • The clasp: looking at its construction and how it closes
  • Does the design match how that piece was made?

A serial number is not a test by itself, and neither is an online photo comparison. Both are easy to copy and easy to misread.

Photograph the marks close enough to read, then have them assessed as a set. A review from photographs is a strong indication, not a final answer, and confirmation happens in hand.

Is Tiffany sterling silver worth more than its scrap value?

It can be. Sterling has a metal value, but a signed, identifiable piece in good condition is also valued on design and demand.

How much more? That depends on the piece, its condition, and what buyers are looking for right now. There is no fixed uplift, and nobody can quote you one before seeing it.

Ask for the estimate broken out, so you can see what is attributed to silver content and what to the piece itself. Not every signed silver item carries value beyond its metal, though: small, heavily worn or very common pieces can come close to their material value.

Does Tiffany buy back used jewelry?

Brand repurchase and trade-in policies are subject to change and can vary by region. Check Tiffany's current position with Tiffany directly rather than relying on a third-party page.

Here are the potential routes:

  • Direct buyer: paid now, against a verified valuation.
  • Consignment: can reach a higher headline figure, but you wait, you carry the risk while it is unsold, and commission comes off the final sale.
  • Auction: wider reach, but with fees and a longer timeline.
  • Pawn shop: the fastest route, and usually the lowest number.

Compare the routes on net proceeds and timing, not headline numbers. Any figure quoted before the piece is examined is an estimate, not an offer.

Will engraving, scratches, or repairs lower the offer?

It depends on which. Ordinary wear and tear is expected on a worn piece and is priced as part of condition. How much it matters varies from piece to piece.

Personal engraving is different. It narrows the pool of buyers who want that exact item, and removing it means removing metal. Non-original repairs and replacement parts also narrow demand, because they change what a buyer is getting.

Photograph engraving and wear clearly, and note any repair or resizing you know about. Do not polish before review: it removes a layer of metal and softens engraved detail, which costs more than the marks it hides.

What should I expect if I take Tiffany jewelry to a pawn shop?

You can expect speed and cash in hand. A pawn shop's business is quick liquidity, and most do not specialize in any one jewelry house, so an offer there may rest mainly on metal and stones, less so on the design or the collection.

Before accepting, get an itemized specialist valuation to compare against: one that says what was identified, what was tested, and what each factor contributed. A pawn offer is usually immediate, and that has real value if you need funds today. The comparison is price against how long you are willing to wait.

How do I avoid being lowballed when selling Tiffany jewelry?

Photograph the signature, hallmarks, clasps and condition before you approach anyone. Then ask each buyer how the brand and the materials were valued separately. A buyer who can only give you one number has not broken the work down. There is more on selling jewelry online without getting scammed.

Compare net proceeds after all fees, shipping and waiting time, and avoid buyers who cannot be verified, will not put terms in writing, or want the piece in hand before quoting. No estimate is final before verification: you are judging whether the reasoning is visible, not whether the first number is the biggest.

How does insured shipping work with Unvault?
  • A free prepaid, fully insured FedEx label.
  • Your piece is examined on camera and you receive video of the inspection.
  • The final offer is itemized for your decision.
  • If you decline, the piece is returned free, along with insured return shipping.
  • Payment is processed one business day after you accept.

You can read about how Unvault works for the full process.

Photograph the piece and the sealed package before it goes, and keep the tracking until you have been paid. Return shipping insurance is limited to the authenticated value of the item.

Ready to see what your jewelry is worth?

Free valuation in 60 seconds. Sell if you want.
Get Instant Valuation
Questions? We’re here to help. Contact us